Voice
Voice

Buying Guide

How to compare project management tool pricing

The price on the card is rarely what you pay, so here is how to read per-seat and flat pricing, plan tiers, seat minimums, yearly billing and add-ons, and work out the real cost for your team.

By Matt Wagner6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Per-user pricing grows with every person you add. Flat pricing stays the same until you hit the plan's limit.
  • The feature you need decides your plan tier, not the team size.
  • Seats are often sold in set sizes, so you may pay for people you do not have yet.
  • Yearly billing is cheaper per month, but you pay for the year up front.
  • Add up seats, tier, billing and add-ons before you compare two tools.

Why the price on the card is not the price you pay

Pricing pages usually lead with their lowest number. It often assumes the cheapest plan, the longest contract, and a team size that might not be yours.

None of that is a trick, exactly. But it means two tools that both say "$10" can end up hundreds of dollars apart a year once you plug in your own team. The fix is to stop comparing card prices and start comparing totals.

Start a decision space

Tell Otis what your team needs and Juukbox lists matching products in order of best fit.

Find project management tools
Voice
No paid placements. Product visibility based solely on your priorities.

Three ways tools charge

Most project management tools use one of these pricing models, or a mix of them.

  • Per user

    You pay a set amount for each person, every month. Add a person, the bill goes up. Many tools charge this way.

  • Flat price

    You pay one price for the whole account, up to a limit on people or projects. Adding someone costs nothing until you hit that limit.

  • Usage

    You pay for how much you use something, like AI requests or automation runs. It is often added on top of one of the other two.

monday.com is per user: its plans are priced per "seat / month." Microsoft Planner is per user too, at "user/month, paid yearly." Basecamp is the flat one. Its business plans say "no per-user fees."

Flat pricing still has limits. They are just on something other than people. Basecamp's lower plans cap active projects and storage, and each one caps users too: Pro is "Up to 10 users" and "Up to 8 active projects."

Plan tiers: find the feature, then find the plan

Nearly every tool sells plans in tiers, from cheap to expensive. Each step up unlocks more features. The question is not "which plan fits our team size?" but "which is the cheapest plan that has everything on our must-have list?"

Take two features many teams want, a timeline (Gantt) view and time tracking, and see where they sit:

monday.comwork managementMicrosoft Planner
Timeline or Gantt viewFrom StandardFrom Planner Plan 1
Time trackingFrom ProNot listed
Baselines and critical pathNot listedFrom Planner and Project Plan 3

Timeline or Gantt view

monday.com
From Standard
Microsoft Planner
From Planner Plan 1

Time tracking

monday.com
From Pro

Baselines and critical path

monday.com
Not listed
Microsoft Planner
From Planner and Project Plan 3
  • monday.com: Basic, the cheapest paid plan, has neither.

So on monday.com, a team that needs time tracking is shopping for Pro, not Standard, whatever Standard costs. Write your must-haves down first, then match each one to a plan.

Minimum seats and seat packs

Some tools do not let you buy any number of seats you like. They sell them in set sizes, so you round up.

monday.com's team size menu starts at 3 seats and then goes 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 40, 50, 100 and "200+ Seats." A team of 12 picks 15 seats and pays for 3 empty ones. Go over your count and monday.com's help center says your plan "is automatically upgraded to the next seat bucket" if you do not remove the extra people within 5 days.

Microsoft Planner lists the number of users as "No restrictions or limits," so you buy one license per person. Basecamp sidesteps the question with its user caps per plan.

Who counts as a seat?

  • Do people who only look, and never edit, need a paid seat?
  • Do clients and freelancers from outside your company count?
  • Is there a smallest number of seats you must buy?
  • What happens to your bill when you add one more person?

Outside peopleThe answers differ a lot. monday.com gives Basic "Unlimited free viewers," and on Standard "every 4 guests count as 1 billed seat," with unlimited guests on Pro. Basecamp says "every person you add is counted," clients and contractors included.

Yearly vs monthly billing

Many pricing pages show the yearly price by default. It is lower per month, but you pay for twelve months at once and you are committed for the year. Always flip the toggle to monthly to see the other number.

monday.com

per seat per month on Standard, billed annually
$12
per seat per month on Standard, billed monthly
$14
monday.com labels its yearly toggle "SAVE 18%."

Some pages show only one option. Microsoft Planner's page lists its paid plans as "paid yearly," an annual subscription that auto renews.

Check what happens if you cancel. Microsoft gives "a 7-day cancellation window to receive a prorated refund" once a paid subscription begins. A good rule: go monthly until you are sure, then switch to yearly.

Add-ons and usage charges

An add-on is anything you pay for on top of the plan. AI is a common one, and it is often priced by usage or as its own per-user license.

monday.comBasecamp
AIAI credits, bought as part of your setupNot listed
More usageMore API calls, bought as neededAn extra 5 TB of storage for $100 a month

AI

monday.com
AI credits, bought as part of your setup
Basecamp
Not listed

More usage

monday.com
More API calls, bought as needed
Basecamp
An extra 5 TB of storage for $100 a month
  • monday.com: The smallest AI credit amount goes up with the tier: 1,000 a month on Basic, 2,000 on Standard, 3,000 on Pro.

monday.com's yearly Standard price for 15 seats showed $200 crossed out to $180, with a "Special offer: $20 off / month." In the page's own breakdown, that $20 is the AI credits line. Offers like this change, so read the breakdown on the day you buy.

Free plans, free trials, and talking to sales

A free plan is free forever, with limits. A free trial is the full product for a short time. They answer different questions: a free plan tells you if the basics fit, a trial tells you if the plan you would actually buy is worth it.

monday.comBasecampMicrosoft Planner
Free planFreeUp to 2 seats and up to 3 boardsFreeOne project, up to 3 peopleBasic Planner, included in Microsoft 365
Trial and credit cardStart free, no credit card needed30 days, no credit card requiredPlanner Plan 1One month, credit card required

Free plan

monday.com
FreeUp to 2 seats and up to 3 boards
Basecamp
FreeOne project, up to 3 people
Microsoft Planner
Basic Planner, included in Microsoft 365

Trial and credit card

monday.com
Start free, no credit card needed
Basecamp
30 days, no credit card required
Microsoft Planner
Planner Plan 1One month, credit card required
  • Microsoft Planner: Microsoft says the trial converts to a paid subscription when it ends, unless you cancel.

Also check whether you can buy without talking to anyone. monday.com's Enterprise plan has a "custom price" and a "Get a quote" button, so you need to go through sales. Basecamp and Microsoft Planner show every price on the page, and you can buy them yourself.

If Microsoft Planner is on your list, ask your IT team first. If your company already pays for Microsoft 365, the basic version may cost you nothing extra.

Work out the real cost for your team

For each tool on your list

  1. Count the people who will use it, and decide who only needs to look.
  2. Find the cheapest plan that has every must-have feature.
  3. Round your headcount up to the seat sizes the tool sells, or check the plan's user cap.
  4. Look up the price for that plan with the billing you will actually choose, yearly or monthly.
  5. Add any add-ons and usage charges you will need, like AI or extra storage.
  6. Multiply by 12 to get a yearly total, then compare the totals.

Seats, rounded upplusPrice of the plan tier you needplusYearly or monthly billingplusAdd-ons and usageequalsYour real cost

Here is a worked example for a team of 12, using each vendor's listed prices before tax:

monday.comBasecampMicrosoft Planner
Plan for a team of 12Standard15 seatsProOne price for the whole accountPlanner Plan 112 licenses at $10
Billed annually, a month$180Not listed$120paid yearly
Billed monthly, a month$210$100Not listed

Plan for a team of 12

monday.com
Standard15 seats
Basecamp
ProOne price for the whole account
Microsoft Planner
Planner Plan 112 licenses at $10

Billed annually, a month

Basecamp
Not listed
Microsoft Planner
$120paid yearly

Billed monthly, a month

  • monday.com: Need time tracking? That is Pro: $285 a month billed annually for 15 seats.

On monday.com Pro, guests are unlimited. The total for your team, not the card price, is the number to compare.

Questions to ask

  1. "Which plan has every feature on our list, and what does it cost for our exact headcount?"

  2. "Who counts as a paid seat: viewers, guests, clients?"

  3. "What is the price if we pay monthly, and what happens if we cancel a yearly plan early?"

  4. "Which features cost extra, like AI, storage or more automation, and how are they measured?"

When you know your team size, your budget per person and your must-haves, describe them in Juukbox to see matching tools in order of fit.

Know what your team needs?

Tell Otis about your team and Juukbox builds a space with matching products in order of best fit.

Find project management tools
Voice
No paid placements. Product visibility based solely on your priorities.

Sources

  1. Pricing, monday.com
  2. How to manage an auto-upgrade, monday.com Support
  3. Pricing for guests, monday.com Support
  4. The pricing model for monday AI portfolio, monday.com Support
  5. Pricing, Basecamp
  6. Compare Planner plans, Microsoft